Call us now!

Hilliard: 614-529-4259
Delaware: 740-369-2886

Meet Our Team

Martin J Mitchell Insurance

Martin J Mitchell InsuranceMartin Mitchell
Agency Owner

As a Personal Financial Representative in Hilliard, I know many local families. My knowledge and understanding of the people in this community help me provide customers with an outstanding level of service. I look forward to helping families like yours protect the things that are important – your family, home, car and more. I can also help you prepare a strategy to achieve your financial goals.

As your insurance agent, I can help you understand how the choices you make – such as the car you drive – affect your insurance rate. I’m committed to helping you get the appropriate level of protection and make it easy to do business with our agency.

B.S. Ohio State University
B.S. The Ohio State University

Civic Services
Knights of Columbus
The Society of CPCUNFIB
The Society of Financial Service Professional

Allstate Leader's Forum-2 years
Honor Ring-8 years

Community Services
Habitat for Humanity
Blast from the Past Car Show
Charity Newsies
St. Brendan Church
St. Mary's Church
The Society of Financial Service Professionals
2012 Readers Choice Award ThisWeek Community News
Hillard Football
Martin J Mitchell InsuranceSamantha Henson

I have worked here at Allstate for 3 years now as a licensed agent.

I grew up in a small town in southeastern Ohio called Gallipolis. You never meet a stranger there!

I want to help people not just sell to people. I genuinely love the feeling when I have made someone happy or helped him or her save money, even if it is just a few dollars.

Personally, I love my husband, my labradoodle (dog) Scarlett, Ohio State Football, reading, and anything fitness related!

You can find me at the gym, yoga, or running with Scarlett in my neighborhood. My husband and I are also huge foodies, so we love to try different restaurants around Columbus and relax and have a few drinks on the weekends.

I would say my guilty pleasure is ice cream, especially in the summertime! A talent is probably that, even though I am getting older, I can still do backflips (it just hurts now).

There are no volunteer activities or non-profits that I am really passionate about, but at Christmas time I try to give at least something to most charities I see.

Martin J Mitchell InsuranceMoriah Mailey

I have had almost two years experience in the insurance industry.

I grew up in Mount Gilead, OH. I attended The Ohio State University where I received a Bachelor's degree in Psychology.

I enjoy helping customers and properly insure their prized possessions.

I really enjoy attending rock and metal concerts.

On the weekends you will find me by the pool, spending time with family, at the racetrack or at a concert.

I am slightly obsessed with flat track motorcycle racing.

Martin J Mitchell InsuranceRobert Redmond


I have worked in Claims, Underwriting and now as a licensed Sales Producer for Allstate.

I Grew up and currently live in Hilliard, Ohio. Graduated from Ohio University in 2009.

I love helping people on a daily basis.

I am a sports fanatic. Can't stop talking about the Ohio State Buckeyes, Cleveland Browns, Cavaliers and Indians as well as the Columbus Blue Jackets.

When I’m not at the office, you’ll definitely find me on the golf course.